Aunt Dimity’s Death by Nancy Atherton

Welcome back to Paperback Throwback, where I highlight a book from my ever-growing collection of older paperbacks, ‘90s and prior. Come check out everything from Zebra’s line of horror to Scholastic’s preteen Apple Paperbacks, and everything in-between— you’ll know them by their stylishly cheesy covers, flashy plots, and cheap prices.

Join me on this stroll down Literary Memory Lane. Stops include Sweet Valley High, Fear Street, and anywhere else mass market paperbacks may be lurking.

This week’s throwback is cozy.

Cozy mysteries have a massive following, and that’s partially because there’s a loose formula that tends to connect these books. Loyal readers know what they’re getting themselves into. Each book in a series involves some mystery that an amateur sleuth feels compelled to solve—almost always a murder, which happens in the first few chapters. There’s a large cast of eccentric characters who both propel and inhibit the investigation. And lightness is key: murders take place off-page and graphic content is toned down, even in serious situations.

But sometimes authors toss out a twist on these usual trends while keeping the spirit of the cozy. The Aunt Dimity series by Nancy Atherton, first published in 1992 and currently comprised of twenty-four titles, is one of the most popular in the genre. However, the first book, Aunt Dimity’s Death—perhaps contrary to the title—features no murder and a mystery that doesn’t reveal itself in an obvious way until nearly halfway through. Yet Aunt Dimity’s Death is perfectly encapsulates the cozy-ish world.

Lori Shepherd always assumed Aunt Dimity was just a character her recently deceased mother created, so she’s incredibly surprised to find that Aunt Dimity has died. The law firm tasked with handling her massive estate, though, is certainly real—and more than happy to provide her with a considerable sum of money so long as she completes the one task Aunt Dimity left for her. Soon, Lori’s off to a charming cottage in the Cotswolds to dig through Dimity’s papers and solve a nearly lifelong mystery … perhaps even with some guidance from the spirit of Aunt Dimity herself.

Atherton keeps things light to the point of quaint, and for a book published nearly thirty years ago, this remarkably keeps it feeling fresh. There’s no real sense of danger for Lori, but this allows for a focused exploration of the personal turmoil she’s going through. It also gives time for all of the quirky characters that surround her to fully evolve into the tight community that will obviously propel the story in future installments. Though the mystery itself binds them together, the heart of the story stems from the shift from childhood to adulthood and the stories we share—a truly unique cozy if there ever was one.

Title: Aunt Dimity’s Death
Series: Aunt Dimity Mystery #1
Author: Nancy Atherton
Publisher: Viking Books
Publication Date: November 1992
Classification: Mystery

Atherton’s Website | Publisher’s Page | Goodreads


  1. As a professional in the world of books, do you have any idea when the term “cozy” mysteries was introduced or became popular? I read classics and mysteries as a teenager, then mainly read books aimed at educators. Fast forward 40 years in the fiction world and I discover cozy mysteries. I’m thrilled but also mystified. Any ideas?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That is an excellent question that I’ve never really thought about! And after some reading I’m not sure I have a solid answer. Based on newspaper archives, my best guess is sometime in the late 1980s. By the ’90s, it shows up pretty regularly— but I’m not sure if the term was also popular with readers or just industry professionals. But even before that, there are a few instances of Agatha Christie novels being referred to as ‘tea cozy mysteries’ and I’m at a total loss as to when this started.


  2. Thanks for the explanation of what a cozy mystery actually is. I’ve been completely baffled by that term and only can recognize them by the similar kinds of covers. This one looks a bit different, but you know what I mean…the bright colors and small town scene, that type of thing. I always feel so much better informed after reading your reviews!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh, I should’ve mentioned the covers! They do tend to stick out, especially when they’re in a bundle of mass market paperbacks. Now I wonder if there’s a term for that art style, or if they’re just ‘cozy covers’ … I’m so glad you get something out of these posts! I feel the exact same way about your reviews.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I was trying to think how to describe the covers when I wrote that, just kind of like…very bright colors heavy on the pink and the orange, lots of balls of yarn, small town or village-y scenes? How do they describe them when commissioning the art, I wonder?

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s